Are You Using Your Brow Pencil Wrong?

June 27, 2025

Are You Using Your Brow Pencil Wrong?

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG?

What's Your Brow Story?

Not all brows behave the same - and that’s exactly the point.  

Maybe yours are thick and full of personality, maybe they’ve thinned over time. Perhaps they’re defined in some spots and sparse in others, but isn’t that the same for everyone? 

Whatever makes your brow story, there’s one tool that will always make all the difference: a high-quality Eyebrow Pencil. 

At BBB London, we believe your brow routine should enhance your natural beauty, not mask it. 


The right Brow Pencil offers soft definition, lasting wear, and a finish that feels totally effortless. No harsh lines. No blocky shapes. Just beautifully balanced brows made easy.

Discover below our expert-curated brow strategy, to unlock the secrets for your best brows yet.

Best Eyebrow Pencils - Sharpened Pencil - BBB London

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG? 

Brow Pencil Basics: What You Need to Know 

Before diving into technique, let’s get grounded in the basics of the world of Eyebrow Pencils.

Not all pencils are created equal, and choosing the right one can completely shift your brow game.  


Types of Brow Pencils
:  

  • Micro-tip pencils: Ideal for precise, hair-like strokes - great for sparse areas.  

  • Waxy formulas: Softer, blendable finish for an all day look.  

  • Retractable tips: No sharpening needed; perfect for on-the-go.  

  • Angled tips: Versatile for filling and shaping in one.   


Key Features to Look For:  

  • Built-in spoolie: Essential for blending and brushing hairs into place.  

  • Long-wear formula: No smudging or fading midday.  

  • Natural pigmentation: Buildable colour that mimics real hair. 

 
Insider Top Tips:
 

  • Don’t settle for one pencil type.
    Keep a micro-tip and an angled pencil on hand - you’ll switch depending on how much time you have or what look you’re going for. 

  • Waxy isn’t weak.
    Softer formulas may seem subtle, but they layer like a dream and last all day without flaking. 

  • Use the spoolie between strokes.
    Don’t just blend at the end - alternate pencil and spoolie for the most seamless finish. 

Brow Pencil Shades - Best Brow Pencils - BBB London

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG? 

How to: Choose the Right Brow Pencil Shade 

Finding your ideal Brow Pencil shade isn’t about matching your hair colour exactly - it’s about finding harmony with your undertone.
  

  • Cool tones (ashy blondes): Best for those with pink or neutral undertones.  

  • Warm tones (chocolate brown) Flatter golden or olive skin.  

  • Dark brows? Go one shade lighter for a softer look.  

  • Light brows? Go one shade deeper for added definition. 

 

Our Eyebrow Pencil collection at BBB London is designed with inclusive shades that suit a variety of skin tones and hair hues, so you never have to compromise. 

 

Insider Top Tips: 

  • Match your undertone, not your hair. A brunette with a warm complexion might need a different shade than one with cooler undertones - even if their hair looks identical. 

  • Try the ‘wrist test.’ Test your pencil shade on the inside of your wrist - it mimics your face's undertone more closely than the back of your hand. 


ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG?

Brow Mapping: Create Your Perfect Brow Shape  

Your ideal brow shape is already there - you just need to reveal it. That’s where brow mapping comes in.  


Step-by-Step Brow Mapping Guide

  1. Start: Align your pencil vertically from your nostril to the inner brow. 

  2. Arch: Pivot the pencil across your iris; that’s your natural arch point. 

  3. End: Angle from the edge of your nose past the outer eye corner.  


Use this technique as a guide before filling.

But don’t worry, we’ve made it easy for you - our team of brow experts designed our BBB London Brow Mapping Stencils kit to take out all of the hard work. 


Insider Top Tips: 

  • Use a brow pencil as your guide stick.
    Even pros do this - it’s the fastest way to visually map with accuracy. 

  • Don’t fear asymmetry.
    Brows are sisters, not twins - use mapping to enhance natural symmetry, not erase individuality. 

  • Highlight your mapping points.
    Dot your start, arch, and end before connecting the shape - it gives you a clearer roadmap when filling in. 

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG? 

How to Fill In Brows Without Overdoing It  

The difference between defined and overdrawn? It’s all in the technique.  

  • Use feather-light strokes to mimic hair. 
     
  • Focus on the middle to tail of your brows, then lightly fill the front.  

  • Blend with the spoolie in upward, outward motions for a diffused finish.  

A great Brow Pencil should feel like an extension of your hand - natural, controlled, and intuitive.

Avoid harsh pressure, and remember: you can always build, but it’s harder to take away. 

 

Insider Top Tips: 

  • Light pressure = natural results.
    Hold the pencil like a makeup brush near the end, not like a pen - this forces a lighter touch. 

  • Strokes should follow hair direction.
    Study your brow growth and replicate it - this is the secret to realism. 

  • Step back.
    Periodically check your brows in a mirror from a slight distance - it’s how others will see you. 

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG? 

Tailored Tips by Brow Type 

 Different brows require different strategies. Here’s how to tailor your Eyebrow Pencil use to suit your specific needs.  


FOR THICK BROWS

Goal: Define, not dominate.

Tip: Use a fine tip pencil to outline the base and arch for structure. Blend gently to maintain a soft edge.  



FOR SPARSE BROWS


Goal
: Fake fullness.

Tip: Opt for a micro-tip Brow Pencil to fill in gaps with hair-like strokes. Focus on mimicking direction and density, not solid colour.  



FOR THIN BROWS


Goal
: Build a natural frame.


Tip: Shape with light outlining, then use short, upward strokes to lift. Finish with a highlighting pencil under the arch to lift and define.  


FOR UNRULY BROWS

Goal: Tame + shape.

  
Tip: Pair your Eyebrow Pencil with a clear or tinted brow gel to set hairs in place. Define only where needed to keep things fresh. 

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG? 

Mistakes to Avoid With a Brow Pencil 

 We’ve all been there. These common mistakes can throw off your whole look, but they’re easily fixable.  

  • Overlining: Stick to your mapped lines for the most flattering shape. 

  • Wrong undertone: A mismatched shade can look stark or add an unnatural halo around your arches.

  • Harsh tails: Keep the tail soft and feathered for a lifted, modern effect. 

  • Skipping the spoolie: Blending is non-negotiable for a natural finish. 


Insider Top Tips: 

  • Use a magnifying mirror with caution.
    It can cause over-filling - always double-check your work in natural light. 

  • Avoid over-filling the tail.
    A blocky tail can drag your face down - keep it lighter than the arch. 

  • Spoolie is your secret weapon.
    If in doubt, blend it out. The spoolie can fix everything from excess pigment to uneven strokes. 

ARE YOU USING YOUR BROW PENCIL WRONG? 

Final Thoughts

The best brows don’t look drawn, they look like yours, just a little more polished.   With the right Eyebrow Pencil, you can define your shape, boost your confidence, and simplify your beauty routine all at once.  


At BBB London, our range of expertly crafted Brow Pencils is designed to work with your natural brows, not against them. Because your brows? They’re already beautiful - you’re just giving them a little extra love. 

 

Explore our full Eyebrow Pencil Collection here and see the difference for yourself. 

STEAL KATE MOSS' GLASTONBURY SECRETS

Why Trust Us With Your Brows?

Because your brows are worth it.

When you work with real brow specialists — not just beauty enthusiasts — you get real results.

  • 20+ years of brow mastery.

  • Loved by celebrities, stylists, and editors across the UK (and beyond).

  • An award-winning team blending traditional techniques with modern artistry.

  • A cult-favourite product range designed by experts, for real results.

Your best brows aren't just about following a trend — they're about creating a look that feels effortlessly you. And that’s exactly what we do best.


Ready to redefine your brows — and your reflection?

Book your consultation at BBB London today.


(And don’t forget to check out our 2025 Brow Trends blog to stay one step ahead.